New York City Rental Guide · Your Questions, Answered
Why Storefronts Sit Empty, and How We Keep Brooklyn Local
By Jason Mezydlo · @JasonMezydlo
Jason Mezydlo · Managing Sales Partner, Gordon Realty Partners
347.286.5797 · jason@gordonrealtypartners.com · JasonMezydlo.com
622 3rd Avenue, New York, NY
One of my Keyed In Brooklyn readers on Substack asked me a question I haven’t been able to stop thinking about. With the new Panda Express and Chipotle in The Slope on Fifth, the new condominium on the corner of Fifth Avenue and Ninth Street in Park Slope, they feel like the face of the neighborhood, or even worse, its soul, might be changing. They wanted to know how commercial rents can be kept in check, how landlords can be nudged to fill storefronts instead of leaving them dark for years, and whether Gowanus is headed the same way.
It’s a fair concern, and it’s one I share. What makes New York feel like New York isn’t just the skyline. Park Slope has long been known for its bohemian cachet, a mix of old-school storefronts, independent boutiques, the Park Slope Food Coop and places like LeRoy’s Place, Mr. Boddington’s Studio and Mockingbird, shops you can’t find anywhere else because they were dreamed up here. So here’s my answer, from someone who works on both sides of the lease.
Why Storefronts Sit Empty
New York has about 15,700 empty storefronts, an 11% vacancy rate, according to a June report from the city comptroller. Brooklyn sits at 12.3%. The comptroller’s office considers 5% or less healthy for a retail strip. The good news closer to home: the city’s planning department counts Park Slope among the few Brooklyn neighborhoods where vacancy hasn’t risen since 2020.
Why would anyone leave a space empty instead of lowering the rent? A few reasons, and none of them is as simple as greed.
- Retail leases are long. Most run ten years, because tenants need time to earn back their build-out. A landlord who signs too low is stuck with it for a decade, so many would rather wait for a better offer. Researchers who studied Manhattan found empty shops stayed vacant for about 16 months on average.
- The bank may not allow it. Many larger buildings carry loans that set a minimum rent on any new lease. One study of these loan terms estimated they pushed vacancy up by as much as 14% from 2016 to 2020. The owner may want to cut the rent and simply not be allowed to.
- Chains look safer on paper. A national brand signs with a corporate guarantee and a long track record. A first-time shop owner, however brilliant, looks like a risk to a lender. That’s how a corridor slowly fills with the same names you see at the airport.
The result is a strange split: from 2020 to 2024, the number of empty storefronts rose nearly 30%, while commercial rents fell only about 6.5%.
The Landlord Math Nobody Talks About
Here’s the part I want every reader to see, because it changes the conversation. I ran the numbers on a typical Fifth Avenue mixed-use building: a storefront with three apartments above, priced like a similar building that sold this spring for $3.5 million.
Bought today, that building earns about 3.8% a year before any mortgage. A 10-year Treasury, with no tenants, no boiler and no risk, pays about 4.9%. With a typical mortgage, the new owner loses money every month and is betting entirely on the building gaining value. If the storefront sits empty for a year, the return falls to about 1%.
So a new owner on Fifth Avenue has every reason to chase the safest tenant on the block. The owner who bought decades ago, with no mortgage and a low cost basis, is the one who can afford to take a chance on a dreamer. Those long-time, small owners are exactly who we should be working to keep in the game. Each time one sells out, the building tends to go to an investor whose only lever is the rent, and whose trade groups have far more pull in Albany than any shop owner.
To be fair, a small landlord isn’t automatically a good one. But on the residential side, a tenant-advocacy analysis found that tenants of landlords with more than 20 buildings were 24% more likely to be evicted than tenants of single-building owners. Scale changes the relationship. When your landlord lives upstairs, you can knock on their door.
What Would Actually Help
I don’t think one law fixes this, and I’m wary of anything that pushes small owners to sell. Here’s what I’d like to see.
- Reward landlords who rent to local, creative businesses. A bill in Albany, S1451A from State Senator Brian Kavanagh, would give a property tax break of up to ten years to landlords who sign small retailers to ten-year leases with raises capped at 3% a year. San Francisco already pays landlords up to $22,500 a year to keep its legacy businesses in place. That’s a carrot, and carrots keep small owners in the game.
- Help the businesses themselves. A tax credit for creative and independent shops, paired with the city’s free Commercial Lease Assistance program, would help a first-time owner sign a lease they can live with.
- Zone creatively. The city’s City of Yes for Economic Opportunity, approved in 2024, already lets a wider range of businesses use ground floors, and Gowanus’s 2021 rezoning calls for active ground floors along key streets. Let’s push for rules that favor makers, studios and small-format shops, not just the biggest tenant.
- Keep building. More commercial space, in places like Sunset Park, takes pressure off rents everywhere. Scarcity is what lets a landlord wait 16 months.
- Watch the stick closely. There are also proposals to tax storefronts left empty more than six months and to create commercial rent stabilization. They’re worth debating, but small owners’ groups warn that blanket controls could push the very landlords we need out of the market.
| Proposal | What it would do | Approach |
|---|---|---|
| S1451ASen. Brian Kavanagh | Up to 10 years of property tax relief for landlords who give small retailers 10-year leases with raises capped at 3% | Carrot |
| Int 0090Council Member Gale Brewer | A Storefront Business Bill of Rights: cost disclosure and a one-time lease extension for tenants in good standing | Tenant protection |
| S8319 / A5568ASen. Julia Salazar, Asm. Emily Gallagher | A commercial Rent Guidelines Board and a right to 10-year lease renewals | Rent regulation |
| S9823, A669Sen. Michael Gianaris, Asm. Linda Rosenthal | Taxes on storefronts left empty more than six months | Stick |
| OPEN for Small BusinessMayor Zohran Mamdani | 50-plus fee and red-tape cuts, plus a city review of commercial rents and chronic vacancy due this fall | Review |
What You Can Do This Month
Show up. Community Board 6, which covers Park Slope and Gowanus, holds its next full board meeting on Wednesday, November 18 at 6:30 p.m. at the Van Alen Institute, 303 Bond Street, and on Zoom. Boards weigh in on liquor licenses, sidewalk cafés and land use, and they listen to the people who come. And on Small Business Saturday, November 28, spend your money at the places you’d miss most.
Gowanus doesn’t have to become a food court. It’ll look like whoever shows up for it.
I’ve asked local officials, lawmakers and small business and property owner groups for comment. This is an ongoing story, and any responses will be added here and flagged as updates.
Let’s Find the Right Fit
If you’re a shop owner hunting for the right space, or a small landlord weighing your next tenant, I’d love to help you find a match that works for both sides of the lease. I know these blocks, I know the numbers, and I’ll walk you through every step.
Reach out to me at 347.286.5797, jason@gordonrealtypartners.com, or JasonMezydlo.com, and follow along on Instagram at @JasonMezydlo for homes, neighborhoods and design ideas.
Sources
- Who’s Minding the Storefronts?, Office of the New York City Comptroller, June 4, 2026
- Storefront Update, Q1 2026, NYC Department of City Planning
- Why do urban storefronts stay empty so long?, Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies
Show all 20 sourcesShow fewer
- The Contractual Origins of High-Rent Urban Blight, on research by Daniel Stackman and Erica Moszkowski, Marginal Revolution
- City storefronts stay empty, but rent won’t come down, City Limits, July 29, 2026
- Albert Dayan sells mixed-use in Park Slope for $3.5M, PincusCo, May 11, 2026
- Brooklyn Retail Report 2024, Real Estate Board of New York
- Average rent in Park Slope, RentCafe, October 30, 2026
- US 10-year Treasury yield, Trading Economics, November 6, 2026
- Examining the Myth of the Mom-and-Pop Landlord, JustFix, March 4, 2020
- Franchise creep on Fifth Avenue takes flavor out of Park Slope, BK Reader, April 5, 2024
- Two retail-focused bills to watch after recent action in Albany, Rosenberg & Estis
- Mamdani admin backs bill to mandate retail lease renewals, The Real Deal, September 2026
- Senator Salazar and Assembly Member Gallagher introduce legislation to stabilize rent for NYC small businesses, New York State Senate, February 17, 2026
- Socialists take aim at commercial rent, City & State, February 20, 2026
- Assembly Bill A669, commercial vacancy tax, New York State Senate
- Mayor Mamdani announces OPEN for Small Business, NYC Mayor’s Office, July 20, 2026
- Council approves City of Yes for Economic Opportunity, CityLand, June 2024
- Legacy Business Rent Stabilization Grant rules, City and County of San Francisco
- Upcoming meetings, Brooklyn Community Board 6
About Jason Mezydlo
Jason Mezydlo is Managing Sales Partner at Gordon Realty Partners and has worked in New York City real estate since 2012. A graduate of the Harrington College of Design with a BFA in interior design, he brings a designer’s eye to every search, helping clients see what a space can become before they sign. Jason began his career in commercial leasing, guiding small business owners through site selection, lease negotiation and space planning, before moving into Manhattan’s luxury rental market and home sales across Manhattan and Brooklyn. A longtime Brooklyn resident, he pairs market expertise with a deep love for the city’s history, art and architecture.
347.286.5797 · jason@gordonrealtypartners.com · JasonMezydlo.com · @JasonMezydlo
Gordon Realty Partners · 622 3rd Avenue, New York, NY · NYS Licensed Real Estate Salesperson