← Back to Jason Mezydlo

New York City Rental Guide · Arts & Happenings

Around the Block, My Park Slope Holiday Shopping Guide


Updated
By Jason Mezydlo · @JasonMezydlo
Jason Mezydlo · Managing Sales Partner, Gordon Realty Partners
347.286.5797 · jason@gordonrealtypartners.com · JasonMezydlo.com
622 3rd Avenue, New York, NY

My holiday loop, a fifteen minute stroll

Hand-drawn map of the Park Slope holiday shopping routeAn ink map of Park Slope from Union Street south to 11th Street, between Fifth Avenue and Prospect Park West. Stop 1, Annie’s Blue Ribbon General Store, is on Fifth Avenue between President and Carroll Streets. A dotted route runs up Carroll Street to Seventh Avenue, where stop 2, Mr. Boddington’s Studio, sits between Carroll Street and Garfield Place, then down Seventh Avenue to 10th Street, where stop 3, Sterling Place, and stop 4, Leroy’s Place, face each other across the avenue. The 7th Avenue F and G station is at 9th Street. Not to scale. FG Union St President St Carroll St Garfield Pl 1st St 2nd St 3rd St 4th St 5th St 6th St 7th St 8th St 9th St 10th St 11th St 1 2 3 4 Not to scale · drawn for JasonMezydlo.com N Hand-drawn map of the Park Slope holiday shopping routeAn ink map of Park Slope from Union Street south to 11th Street, between Fifth Avenue and Prospect Park West. Stop 1, Annie’s Blue Ribbon General Store, is on Fifth Avenue between President and Carroll Streets. A dotted route runs up Carroll Street to Seventh Avenue, where stop 2, Mr. Boddington’s Studio, sits between Carroll Street and Garfield Place, then down Seventh Avenue to 10th Street, where stop 3, Sterling Place, and stop 4, Leroy’s Place, face each other across the avenue. The 7th Avenue F and G station is at 9th Street. Not to scale. FG Union President Carroll Garfield 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th 6th 7th 8th 9th 10th 11th 1 2 3 4 Not to scale · drawn for JasonMezydlo.com N
  1. Annie’s Blue Ribbon General Store
    232 Fifth Avenue
  2. Mr. Boddington’s Studio
    153 Seventh Avenue
  3. Sterling Place
    352 Seventh Avenue
  4. Leroy’s Place
    353 Seventh Avenue

Every year I tell my family the same proud little fact: I can finish nearly my entire holiday shop in a couple of laps around the blocks a few steps from my apartment. With more than a dozen nieces and nephews scattered across the country, that is no small boast, and being the only one of us in New York means I get to send home treasures nobody else in the family could find. It is also a big part of why settling into South Slope, and staying for more than a decade, was never a hard decision.

The shops below are where I go early and where I go back. Each one sells things made by hand or chosen with real care, and that homespun specialness is what draws me in. But this is more than a list of gift ideas. These are places woven into the culture and spirit of Park Slope, run by people with stories as memorable as anything on their shelves, so I asked them to tell those stories in their own words, and I did some digging of my own.

The route is easy: start on Fifth Avenue, cut up Carroll Street to Seventh, and stroll south toward 10th Street, where two of these shops face each other across the avenue.

Annie’s Blue Ribbon General Store

232 Fifth Avenue, between President and Carroll Streets

The blue storefront of Annie’s Blue Ribbon General Store, its windows painted with ski chalets and reindeer above shelves of holiday gifts
Annie’s on Fifth Avenue, windows dressed for the season. Photo: courtesy of Annie’s Blue Ribbon General Store

Annie’s became a staple for me early on, and it is always my first stop. I am big on handwritten cards with personal notes, so every season starts here with a few boxes of cards. The selection is so well curated, landing right at the intersection of cheekiness and great design, that I have never once walked out disappointed.

The shop began as a long-held dream. “We opened in Boerum Hill in 2007,” Annie told me, “in 500 sq feet tucked away off of Atlantic Avenue,” after more than a decade of planning. This is her 20th holiday season. Park Slope came calling when Skaredy Kat, a fellow small business moving to North Carolina, asked Annie to take over its Fifth Avenue spot because they wanted “a cool shop” to follow them. Thirteen years later, Annie still lives “right around the corner (literally!),” a hyper-local owner in every sense.

The name carries its own story. “The blue ribbon is symbolic of the best that life has to offer,” Annie explained, a nod to the blue ribbons she chased in 4H as a kid. “We pick everything out very lovingly,” and since the team shops like their customers do, the shelves are stocked with what you would want for your own family.

A bright shop with navy walls, pineapple wallpaper, a wall of greeting cards and a center table of red and pink gifts on a navy rug
The card wall, the pineapple wallpaper and a center table in holiday reds. Photo: courtesy of Annie’s Blue Ribbon General Store
A gift table piled with cookbooks, games, candy and a clear tower of colorful socks
Games, cookbooks, candy and a tower of socks, all within arm’s reach. Photo: courtesy of Annie’s Blue Ribbon General Store
1 of 2

What Annie would put in your hands this season

A Scrabble set packaged like a tartan-covered book with gold lettering
The Tartan Bookshelf edition of Scrabble. Photo: courtesy of Annie’s Blue Ribbon General Store
A Christmas Music Trivia box patterned with pears and partridges, tied with twine on a little red wooden sleigh
Christmas Music Trivia, delivered on its own little sleigh. Photo: courtesy of Annie’s Blue Ribbon General Store
A glass mushroom lamp swirled in coral and pale pink
A glass mushroom lamp, back in new colors. Photo: courtesy of Annie’s Blue Ribbon General Store
1 of 3

Mr. Boddington’s Studio

153 Seventh Avenue, between Carroll Street and Garfield Place

A framed hand-lettered sign in red reading Toss Your Phone Into the Sea, between a pinboard of handwritten notes and shelves of cards
The house philosophy, hand-lettered in red. Photo: Jason Mezydlo
A wooden writing desk with a red rotary phone, a red typewriter and a brass lamp beneath a collage wall titled Mr. Boddington’s Society of Correspondence
The Society of Correspondence desk, with a red rotary phone, a typewriter and a wall of letters to anyone. Photo: Jason Mezydlo
A wall of illustrated greeting cards on wooden ledges above a rack of colorful cookbooks and children’s books
Wall-to-wall illustrated cards above shelves of cookbooks and picture books. Photo: Jason Mezydlo
A long wooden table of notebooks, sketchbooks, pens and washi tape in a deep red shop with arched shelving
Notebooks, pens and washi tape on the center table, with the 153 door behind. Photo: Jason Mezydlo
1 of 4

Mr. Boddington’s is the newest addition to my rounds, yet it sits in its space as if it has somehow always been there. The design is elegant and intelligent, with an old-world flair that feels like a drawing room in Oscar Wilde’s London manse. The lighting is perfect, the staff are helpful without hovering, and the open workshop in back, seen through floor-to-ceiling walls of iron and plate glass, makes every visit stimulating and joyful.

The man on the sign never existed. Mr. Boddington was founder Rebecca Ruebensaal’s imaginary friend when she was a child, and he grew up to become the voice of her stationery brand: a well-traveled gentleman in an old house in Antibes, partial to cribbage, tonic and newspapers from Cairo to Tokyo. Rebecca started more than twenty years ago making bespoke invitations for Manhattan brides, a leap into paper that, by the studio’s own telling, left her parents “understandably concerned.” The brand went on to sell hand-illustrated stationery in shops around the world and to design for Paperless Post.

The Brooklyn flagship opened last fall, when Rebecca joined forces with Courtney Ebner, a longtime Park Slope parent who opened the design-minded toy shop Norman & Jules just across the avenue more than a decade ago. Together they built a store devoted to “the lost art of old-fashioned shopkeeping,” with a motto that sums up why I keep coming back: “In a world increasingly lived on screens, we believe in living a little more on paper.”

What I reach for here

Mr. Boddington’s is a chic addition to Park Slope, and one I hope stays for a generation.

Sterling Place

352 Seventh Avenue at 10th Street

A shop floor of crystal stemware, green glass tumblers, brass rabbit bookends, games and mini notebooks, with an ornament tree glowing in the back
Crystal, brass and a game for every table, with the ornament tree glowing in back. Photo: Jason Mezydlo
A gilded parrot wall sconce with a dark drum shade, hung among framed prints on a teal wall
A gilded parrot sconce holding court among the framed prints. Photo: Jason Mezydlo
A wooden drawer of matchboxes printed with vintage labels, above compartments of brass compacts and silver teapot tea infusers
Vintage-label matchboxes from Match Design Factory, with brass compacts and teapot tea infusers. Photo: Jason Mezydlo
An ornate gilded decorative harp on a table beside racks of greeting cards
A gilded harp that stops browsers in their tracks. Photo: Jason Mezydlo
1 of 4

Sterling Place has been a staple for me for years, and a key part of how my home looks in every season. Look around my apartment and you will find their pieces on the shelves, on the walls and on the table. The proprietors have a gift for pairing the new with the antique, and their taste never misses.

The shop is the work of husband-and-wife team Robert Wilson and Elizabeth Crowell, who left marketing jobs at an internet company to open their own store and named it after their Park Slope street. The Seventh Avenue shop has been at the corner of 10th Street since the late 2000s, with a larger sister store on Atlantic Avenue in Boerum Hill. For years the couple drove out to country auctions several times a month, hunting desks, dressers and “country house cast-offs” to refurbish and bring home to Brooklyn.

Their idea is simple and lovely. Elizabeth once described it as “taking existing objects and giving them new life,” and only pieces with true heirloom potential make the cut. The sign out front promises “eclectic curiosities and essentials,” and the store delivers, sized just right for Slope apartments, with smaller furniture, clocks, globes, fine pens and paper among the finds.

Worth a look this season

Leroy’s Place

353 Seventh Avenue, across from Sterling Place

The pink throne beneath the hand-sculpted Leroy’s Place sign. Video: Jason Mezydlo
A green sock puppet with pink antennae topped in yellow pom-poms and a pink sweatband
A sock-puppet alien in a sweatband, ready for its close-up. Photo: Jason Mezydlo
A shaggy knitted monster with button eyes and clay fangs climbing out of a vintage needlepoint in a gilded frame
A knitted monster climbing out of a thrifted needlepoint. Photo: Jason Mezydlo
A lime green sculpted monster with big ears, googly eyes and pink spots standing on a shelf
A one-of-a-kind sculpted monster, waiting for the right home. Photo: Jason Mezydlo
A papier-mache roller coaster called Splat Mountain, with a grinning monster in a polka-dot party hat riding a pink car down the track
Splat Mountain, a hand-built roller coaster with a party-hatted monster in the front car. Photo: Jason Mezydlo
A giant papier-mache sun with a toothy grin, crooked sunglasses and scoops of mint ice cream on its head
The grinning papier-mâché sun, sunglasses askew and topped with mint chip. Photo: Jason Mezydlo
A long white shop with a black and white checkerboard floor, a sculpted tree with turquoise paper leaves, a smiling sun in sunglasses and monster paintings in gilded frames
Checkerboard floors, a paper-leaf tree and monsters in gilded frames. Photo: Dylan Johnson, courtesy of Leroy’s Place
Serene Bacigalupi in a red beanie, smiling with an armful of plush toys, a pigeon, a wizard puppet, a pizza box and a puzzle
Serene Bacigalupi with an armful of holiday finds. Photo: courtesy of Leroy’s Place
A shelf wall under a hand-lettered Fauxdega sign, stocked with joke groceries like canned unicorn, butter-shaped erasers and tortilla chip clips
The Fauxdega, where nothing is what it seems, from chip clips to canned unicorn. Photo: courtesy of Leroy’s Place
A giant pink and gold throne with a crown beside a wall of framed monster paintings and a card rack
A throne fit for a monster, just inside the door. Photo: Dylan Johnson, courtesy of Leroy’s Place
1 of 9

Right across the street, Leroy’s Place never fails to impress. Walking in feels like stepping onto a movie set, as if Tim Burton and Jim Henson somehow produced a more colorful lovechild. Giant puppets lean over the aisles, a monster builds a “sandwich castle” in the window, and every visit I find a gift I know no one else could duplicate, with endless fun along the way. For an uncle with a whole gaggle of nieces and nephews to impress, that matters.

The world of Leroy’s Place began with owner Serene Bacigalupi’s paintings, which reimagine vintage landscapes with whimsical monsters. She grew up traveling to craft fairs with her artist parents in Oklahoma, and when she sold her own work at fairs, her booth sign read “Leroy’s Place.” People started calling her Leroy, and the name stuck so well that she and her husband, chef Paul D’Avino of Café Mars in Gowanus, later gave it to their son. After teaming with New Orleans puppeteer Jacques Duffourc to build the giant puppets, she opened on Seventh Avenue, and later a sister shop on Royal Street in New Orleans.

“Leroy’s Place is celebrating our 8th year in Park Slope this Dec.,” Serene told me. “It may not be the first place you’d expect to find a ‘monster store,’ but I think that’s part of what makes it work!” She loves that in New York “you never know what you might stumble upon,” and hopes the shop gives people a sense of discovery. “We feel so grateful that our unusual concept has been embraced by the neighborhood, and I’m proud to call Park Slope home.”

The shelves hold the work of around 100 artists and makers, from New York to around the world. “We commission small collections of handmade items, so we often only have a few of each thing,” Serene said, which means new work arrives almost daily and “the gift you find is often one-of-a-kind!”

What Serene would point you to

A Few More Neighbors, by Recommendation

I asked each shop which neighbor deserves a shout-out, and their answers make a fine second lap.

Why It Matters

What ties these four together is care. A card chosen for its wit, a sheet of paper too beautiful to waste, an antique given a second life, a monster no one else will ever own. Shops like these are a big part of what makes a neighborhood feel like home, and they are a quiet reason people fall for Park Slope and decide to stay. Every gift bought here keeps that spirit on the block for another season.

Heading to Sunset Park? My Industry City holiday makers guide picks up where this one leaves off.

Find Your Place in Park Slope

If you are thinking about making Park Slope or South Slope your home, or you already live here and are weighing your next move, I would love to help you find the right place, steps from shops like these.

Reach out to me at 347.286.5797, jason@gordonrealtypartners.com, or JasonMezydlo.com, and follow along on Instagram at @JasonMezydlo for more of my favorite corners of Brooklyn.

Sources

Quotes from Annie’s Blue Ribbon General Store and Leroy’s Place come from my interviews with each shop, November 2026.

  1. About Mr. Boddington, Mr. Boddington’s Studio
  2. Husband & Wife Team Brings Food, Fun, and Monsters to Park Slope and Gowanus, Park Slope Pulse (December 2024)
  3. Seeking Decorative Inspiration at Sterling Place, Patch (March 2011)
Show all 14 sourcesShow fewer
  1. New This Week: Mr. Boddington’s Studio, Woods Grove, Formosa Dumplings, Il Leone & More, Park Slope Pulse (August 2025)
  2. Studio Tour: Mr. Boddington’s Studio, Brooklyn Bride (July 2010)
  3. The Art of the Last-Minute Holiday Party with Mr. Boddington’s Studio’s Rebecca Ruebensaal, Paperless Post (November 2025)
  4. Norman & Jules: A Toy Store for Design Lovers, Brooklyn Magazine (December 2012)
  5. For Mom, Brooklyn Paper
  6. Sterling Place, Brooklyn, N.Y., Italian Stationery Blog (May 2022)
  7. Brooklyn Themed Gifts, Sterling Place
  8. Monsters and Puppets Bring Quirky Art Shop to Life in Park Slope, News 12 (June 2025)
  9. Leroy’s Place, Atlas Obscura
  10. Leroy’s Place Brooklyn, Leroy’s Place
  11. Annie’s Blue Ribbon General Store, Time Out New York

About Jason Mezydlo

Jason Mezydlo

Jason Mezydlo is Managing Sales Partner at Gordon Realty Partners and has worked in New York City real estate since 2012. A graduate of the Harrington College of Design with a BFA in interior design, he brings a designer’s eye to every search, helping clients see what a space can become before they sign. Jason began his career in commercial leasing, guiding small business owners through site selection, lease negotiation and space planning, before moving into Manhattan’s luxury rental market and home sales across Manhattan and Brooklyn. A longtime Brooklyn resident, he pairs market expertise with a deep love for the city’s history, art and architecture.

347.286.5797 · jason@gordonrealtypartners.com · JasonMezydlo.com · @JasonMezydlo
Gordon Realty Partners · 622 3rd Avenue, New York, NY · NYS Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

Anything you think I’m missing? Let me know what’s going on in your hood →